Hello dear
Welcome to Donatos Pizza Buckeye Lake
At Donatos Pizza Buckeye Lake, we believe that great pizza brings people together. Our story begins with a commitment to quality, offering signature pizzas like the Hot Chicken Pizza and the Works, crafted with fresh ingredients and family recipes. Located in the heart of Buckeye Lake, we proudly serve both delivery and takeout, ensuring that deliciousness is just a phone call away. Our guests rave about the exceptional taste and friendly service, creating a welcoming atmosphere for all. Whether you're indulging in our famed Very Vegy or savoring our irresistible cinnamon bread, Donatos promises a culinary experience that feels like home.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Party Meatball Shareable
Party Chef
Chicken Harvest Party
Chicken Bacon Ranch Party
About
Donatos Pizza Buckeye Lake
Welcome to Donatos Pizza Buckeye Lake, where delicious pizza and a warm atmosphere come together to create an unforgettable dining experience! Located at 11048 Hebron Rd, Buckeye Lake, OH 43008, this pizza haven has quickly become a local favorite, which is not surprising considering the rave reviews from customers.
Donatos Pizza Buckeye Lake specializes in crafting mouthwatering pizzas that cater to every craving. One standout offering is the Create Your Own Pizza, allowing pizza lovers to select up to six toppings from a wide variety of meats, veggies, and cheeses all for just $7.79. This gives each customer the opportunity to unleash their creativity and tailor their meal exactly to their liking.
- Shareables: In addition to their amazing pizzas, Donatos offers a range of shareables, such as Side and Full Bread Sticks with a choice of marinara sauce for dipping. The standout here is the Asiago Cheese Bread—a fresh-baked artisan pull-apart bread topped with Asiago and Romano, perfect for sharing with friends or indulging in all by yourself!
- Customer Favorites: Testimonials from loyal patrons like Olivia M. emphasize not only the fantastic pizza but also the welcoming service, calling it "the best pizza in Licking County." Others rave about the variety of veggie toppings that create a truly savory experience.
- Consistency and Quality: Even those who experienced earlier bumps in the road have noted significant improvements in the taste and service, highlighting the progress this location has made to become one of the better Donatos in the region.
What sets *Donatos Pizza Buckeye Lake* apart isn’t just the flavorful dishes; it's also the incredible staff who make each visit memorable. From the quick service to the friendly smiles, like those from server Tabby, enthusiasts from all over are drawn back not just for the food but for the community connection.
If you’re in the area or planning a visit, Donatos Pizza Buckeye Lake is more than just a place to grab a slice; it's a welcoming hub where every meal is an event worth sharing. So gather your friends and family, and swing by to experience the unparalleled taste and friendly atmosphere that has everyone talking!
For more scrumptious details or to place an order, you can contact them at (740) 928-7174.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ pizza is amazing, workers are so nice and make you feel welcome. definitely recommend best pizza in licking county ”
“ We get pizza and subs from this location often. Always pretty good. Pretty good like a lot of different Donatos. Not sure why the low rating. The staff are always nice when I pick up food. ”
“ Veg pizza amazing ... full of variety of toppings ....always the best.... Great value and exceptional taste ”
“ They had a rough start.. First month or so they still tasted like "catfish Charlie's" (nastiest "pizza" EVER!) Now theyre one of the better donatos locations... Truly good food! Faster than most local shops too.. I ordered last night online, it said it would be here at 6:42 (45 mins).. It arrived at 6:21. Hot, fresh and absolutely delicious!! Best pizza we've had in years! And the subs... Well, a big don is a big don.. Cant go wrong there ;) Tried the new "asiago brick street bread"... Holy SH!T!!!! Never wouldve believed bread could be sooo good! 4 thumbs up! (theres 2 of us lol) ”
“ I used to frequent Donatos when I worked in this area. We only had a 1/2 hour lunch, but we made it a point to rush over, eat and run. I mean, who doesn't love good pizza? Next question: Who doesn't love All-You-Can-EAT pizza? The baker always kept it coming and would often make a pizza according to your specifications, if you asked (make sure sure it's something others would actually like...). Sadly, when I left job, I had to say to goodbye to the servers, knowing I would be working closer to home, in Columbus. It was over 3 years before I decided (on my day off) to take my kids out there for some more "AYCE" pizza. I can't begin to say how delighted I was to find my server (Tabby) there, greeting people with her sunshine smile and giving love to everyone dining in. She always made it such a pleasnt experience. She greeted me with a wonderful hug (she even recognized me, immediately upon my entry) and took a few moments to catch me up on life since we left. Yes, I will be back, not just for the great price (which includes the drink) but because they know how to keep quality personnel. I'm sure they and the customers reward her handsomely, and you should too... ...and be sure to ask for Tabby (Tell 'em Kenny sent ya!)!! Enjoy! ”
